In the last week of the Systems theory class the topic we talked about was entropy. As far as I understood the subject entropy is a physical term that describes chaos which destroys the order of a closed system. That is often irreversible. One example I remember from class is putting milk into a coffee – the milk mixes with the coffee and cannot be isolated again, so both orders of the systems, the milk and the coffee have changed. But at the same time, they created a new system, which I love by the way! And this brings me to a thought that has been supported by the video “The Physics of Entropy and the Origin of Life” that can be found on the main page of the course. In the video the speaker talks about certain systems that might be seen as disordered or even some kind of chaos from a specific perspective. This kind of view is often limited to a part aspect of the whole but when the perspective changes to a comprehensive view it is visible that those aspects form a functionable, beautiful system! Those systems could be spectacular things such as weather phenomena or the universe itself but can be also very small systems like the traffic in Athens.
Thinking of this phenomenon it is not farfetched to transfer it to the life of a human being and the world we live in from a sociological perspective. I want to take you with me on a train of thought about entropy in different systems.
While watching the video I mentioned before I started thinking about the concepts chaos and order. How often we find ourselves in situations where we look back at a period of our life and suddenly all those chaotic adventures and experiences assemble to a completed entity that just make sense?! Or how often we act chaotic from an outside view but in our reality the chaos is actually a specific order that is understandable just for ourselves?! Quit often, I would assume. At least I can affirm both questions for my own.
I myself never understood why I have to clean up my room because I had and still have a very specific kind of order in it whenever it’s not cleaned up in the view of others: It might seem like everything is at a random place, it’s impossible for them to see my system but I know exactly where everything is. Then I clean up my room and can’t find my stuff anymore… So, the first conclusion that I want to make a note of, as simple as it may sounds like, is that a chaos to you is maybe or most probably an order for someone else.
Which brings me to my next step of this train of thought: Chaos is accompanied by such a negative connotation! Whenever we mark something as chaotic, we mean it’s bad, it’s stressful, it is something not acceptable, something that says about us that we are unorganized, we don’t have – whatever we are talking about – under control. The integration of chaos as a negative term starts at the very beginning of our lives when our parents say sentences to us like “Your room is a chaos, clean it up!”, “Separate your school stuff from your toys!” and so on. Later it’s not getting better: The society wants us to have our life completely in order by the age of eighteen and we are blamed if we don’t follow those expectations. We have been educated according to those moral concepts for our whole lives. I’m wondering where this dividing of things into tidy good stuff on the one hand and the chaotic, bad stuff at the other hand started and why it has such a high priority for people. Maybe because order helps the majority of people to live their daily life, but what we tend to forget is that sometimes it is helpful to reorder certain aspects of living and to do so we need to allow the chaos to exist. Furthermore, the chaos can be responsible for new connections and contexts that we would never see if we exiled the chaos out of our lives. Another reason why people love order might be the need of being functional. And I would suggest that order is one of the requirements of functionality. A characteristic that is essential for the modern society. But it is also undeniable for the survival of human beings? Yes it is, but maybe not in the way we’re thinking!
Let’s have a look at a bigger system than an individual life: The society is a system that has a certain order itself and maintaining this order is the key to our modern life as we know it nowadays. One part of that is to integrate us in that order. This process is called socialization and is indeed a super complex topic that I will definitely not explain in all details in this blog post. But I’m sure we all know the most important parts of this process: We learn how to behave in the society by learning about it in very different ways, such as being educated by others, watching others and learning from experience. In fact, all humans who live in a society are a part of holding it together and create a never-ending process of learning and creating at the same time, as we know from talking in class. This system helps us to orientate ourselves, create routines and make daily life simpler.
Another aspect that I want to point out here is that the society is formed and constantly influenced by humans. It is not a natural system like the water cycle or the moon phases. In my opinion to not treat these matters equally is extremely important: The main difference between them is in my opinion that in natural systems events that are not planned in timing, extend and exact consequences, are included into the system. To us it might seem like disorder or even chaos but in fact the processes are connect with each other in a fluent way and create a complex system that has thousands of functions. The systems specific order is characterized by an uncontrollable interacting of processes while within systems created by humans other rules apply. Humans try to get rid of every disordered and uncontrollable part of the system because we tend to believe a system is only functionable if it is completely ordered by our definition of order. Otherwise, it would be claimed as chaotic. It is so important to keep in mind that there is more than one definition of order and I think we chose the wrong one, but more about this later.
I think the particular reason why humans chose that kind of order is the fear of losing control combined with the goal of improving things till perfection. Politicians, big companies and organizations want to reach the highest and the best. Of course, the direction of goals depends on the political beliefs and the interests, but what all parts of the society have in common is the non-stop derivative in sometimes unbelievable speed. Natural systems behave different: We all know they are changing as well but compared to the society very slowly – except the changes for which people are responsible like the climate crisis. Not every single part is perfect in nature, therefor our environment is characterized by balance. And balance is the central character of nature. Something that is clearly missing in the society. As I tried to make clear before, all kind of systems have an order, it’s just a different one.
Along my train of thought we are now at the point where I have to ask: Is it really necessary to choose control and improvement till perfection over balance? Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate human skills of developing, engineering, integrating as much people as possible, implement human rights, discovering new places, learning about the world we live in and every other thing that we have accomplished without hurting others. But along that journey we, the human race, have done so many horrible things and we keep doing them. We have established a system, the capitalism, that is about to ruin several other systems: the society, the nature and the whole world. Would it not be a good idea to slow down the speed of developing and at the same time renew the balance of living together? Renew our relationship with ourselves, with animals and nature that humans had once? For me the answer is clear.
To build a bridge to the subject of entropy and the title of this reflection: I think the chaos that destroyed and still destroys the world system is the capitalism. We should come back to an understanding of the world as a whole system where we are a part of and which we can influence towards a more wholistic version.
greetings, your alwayshungryandtired